Manchester United’s first signing of the summer time, Tyrell Malacia has induced a buzz amongst followers.
The 22 12 months outdated was set to signal for Olympique Lyon earlier than United swooped in and hijacked the deal for £13 million plus add-ons.
Erik ten Hag is alleged to be a eager admirer of the participant, whom he watched carefully when taking part in within the Eredivisie.
Nevertheless, many United followers had been left stunned on the membership signing a left again, particularly when choices can be found.
Luke Shaw and Alex Telles stored rotating for the left again spot final season.
With the arrival of Malacia, it’s virtually sure that considered one of them may go away the membership.
Allow us to examine and analyse the three full backs, and see which one can be appropriate for Ten Hag’s model of play.
Smarterscout drew out a chart evaluating the three in numerous offensive and defensive areas. It’s based mostly off their performances final season.
Manchester United LBs:
🏴 Attacking output
🇳🇱 Defending high quality
🇳🇱 Defending amount
🇳🇱 Ball retention
🏴 Aerial duels
🇳🇱 1v1s in possession
🏴 1v1s out of possession
🇧🇷 Ending in open play
— smarterscout (@smarterscout) July 6, 2022
One can decipher that Alex Telles is the weakest of the three. The Brazilian’s kind in the direction of the top of final season was dreadful, to say the least.
His poor positioning and lack of physicality price United many objectives. On the assault, he was reluctant to tackle his man and infrequently stopped to play a protected go as a substitute.
From subsequent season, it appears like a direct shootout between Shaw and Malacia for the beginning spot.
The Englishman is healthier aerially, and whereas defending 1-v-1 conditions. Malacia however is extra explosive and direct.
The 22 12 months doesn’t draw back from taking his man on and is understood for placing in harmful low crosses to feed the striker.
He’s additionally superior defensively and makes use of his pace to catch incoming wingers down the road. Final season he gained a staggering 99% of his floor duels whereas in possession.
Lastly, Malacia is comfy on the ball, a top quality that can impress Ten Hag.
Shaw may get the nod initially of the season, however don’t be stunned if switches mid-way by way of the marketing campaign.
I nonetheless have loads of religion in Luke Shaw: I feel Malacia & Shaw may present a supercharged left-side for #MUFC. Alex Telles needs to be simple to maneuver on. Now, time to take a look at the right-hand facet of the pitch & midfield. The #MUTOUR22 will probably be fascinating for us all to check… https://t.co/oalbqVkxuP
— Rob Blanchette (@_Rob_B) July 6, 2022
Journalist Rob Blanchette additionally states: “I nonetheless have loads of religion in Luke Shaw: I feel Malacia & Shaw may present a supercharged left-side for United“
“Alex Telles needs to be simple to maneuver on. Now, time to take a look at the right-hand facet of the pitch & midfield. The pre-season tour will probably be fascinating for us all to check…”